Susan Milligan writes in the Globe today about Mr. G and his trump card – September 11, 2001. You remember, right? That was the day some three thousand people got their asses killed by fanatics. Mr. G harps on that day constantly in his lust for Presidential power. The man’s walking on the bones of the dead to get another job in politics.
Milligan notes that just six seconds into a speech in Delaware:
“I’ll tell you the reason I wear this flag,” (Giuliani said) pointing to the American flag pin on his lapel. “Before September 11, I only wore this flag rarely. But I started wearing it everyday now. Each time I wear it, it reminds me of September 11.”
Nice touch, Mr. G. Too bad the dead can’t vote, eh?
But the thing about 9/11 is that no one seems to be able to identify what Mr. G did that merits his iconic status as a hero of that day. Even his supporters have trouble with that:
Giuliani’s supporters lavish him with praise for his handling of 9/11. At a recent Giuliani event, many said they could not recall any specific thing Giuliani did the day of the attacks. But, they say, Giuliani’s very presence in the streets of Manhattan after the attack – a stark contrast to President Bush, who was absent from public view for hours after the tragedy – displayed strong leadership and courage.
“He took control,” said Carolyn Mercadante, 70, a Delaware voter who came to see Giuliani speak. “Just the fact that he was such a presence there” in New York the day of the attacks, said 67-year-old Bill Uranko of Middleton, Del., when asked to explain what impressed him about Giuliani’s Sept. 11 performance. “You could see he was visibly moved by what happened.”
Well, hell’s bells, I was visibly moved too. How about I get elected President? Damn, that’s it, I’m officially announcing my candidacy for President of the United States. Send me some money, folks. We’re gonna rout these pretenders.
So, let’s see, Rudy pretty much just walked around wiping the dust off himself. Just like everybody else was doing. He didn’t save anybody’s life. He didn’t dig in the ruins for survivors. He didn’t even have a place to go because the disaster command center he set up years before was in the World Trade Center, at his insistence. You know, in one of the towers that went down, in the towers that were the biggest, most obvious targets in the city. Sure, you remember, the towers that were attacked in 1993. Smart man, that Mr. G.
Then we have the firefighter, from Maryland, who thinks Mr. G “stands out as someone who would protect the nation. ‘We need a person who is going to take on the terrorists. It’s the real thing.”
What’s this guy think Mr. G is gonna do? Go to the Middle East and challenge al Qaeda to a fist fight? “Take on the terrorists”? Give me a break. Mr. G not only couldn’t protect his own city, he refused to take steps that would have protected the city’s first responders.
After the 1993 attacks, he knew that the radio system used by firefighters and police was a failure. He knew there were systems that would work in disaster situations. He refused to provide police and firefighters with a proper system. In effect, he signed the death warrants of hundreds of firefighters in the towers on 9/11. Atta boy, Mr. G!
And yet, here’s Rep. Dave Reichert, Washington State chairman of Mr. G’s campaign there.
“The mayor may have more credibility in this [antiterrorism] area than some of the other candidates. He has the experience to back up his comments.”
No, he doesn’t, Dave. He didn’t do anything to fight terrorism on or before 9/11. He hasn’t done anything since to fight terrorism. In fact, he blew off the Iraq Commission, of which he was reputed to be a member, so he could go out and campaign. You’re blowing smoke, Dave, and it’s coming out of your butt.
And finally, Fred Siegel, a history professor who wrote a book on Mr. G, said, “Giuliani governed against the grain. He alienated every interest group in New York, which is why he accomplished so much.”
I would note that George W. Bush, the current sicko occupant of the Presidency, has alienated just about everyone on the planet except Tony Blair, by ‘governing against the grain’. So, what Mr. G is offering us is four to eight more years of Bushian psychopathy as a philosophy of government.
No thanks, Rudy. Maybe you ought to just go back to New York and get a job digging bone fragments from the sewers around the World Trade Center. Then you can say you actually did something useful about 9/11.
Thanks for pointing this out. I’ve been wondering what exactly did he do to earn his “credibility,” besides good marketing. We are beyond amazed that our own Louisiana Senator David Vitter is leading the support for Guiliani. WTF?
Thanks for writing this! I thought I was the only one. I’ve been afraid to ask—”but what did he do?”—wondering if I slept through something the whole world knew about except me.
And thank you for being a good and brave writer.
Mr Gouliani knew there was another plane coming into New York. How come Mr. G didn’t tell the people in the second tower to evacuate?????? They were being told to go back to work. How come Mr. G didn’t go to his command center in building 7 ????? Is it because he knew it was loaded with explosives ?????? Looks like Mr. Gouliani let the people of New York down big time. How did Mr Gouliani know the towers were going to fall?????
Please stop thinking. Is unwanted, unhelpful and unpatriotic. Please stop your thinking, or we will stop it for you.
As a european i heard Mr Gouliani at a keynote speech for a big corporation, i didnt go for him alone speaking, or do i understand the rules of american football.
Terrorism is ‘Bush fud’
So what did i a european in america at a conference learn about the hero of 9/11 after 2001.
1. not much
2. mr g is a bit of ships figurehead – think sailing boats
3. any prior disaster plans where a failure (hence his appearance)
‘Sympathy’ was what i came away with. I did not think much of him. This was before any presidential campaigning
While ’sorry’ is a reason, its a bad reason to vote
Yeah, standing victoriously on top of a giant heap of rubble and ashes? That is frighteningly ominous when it comes to Giuliani’s potential presidency.
That’s our Giules. Prince of Idle Idols.
I too, wondered what the heck Giuliani did. I don’t follow the issues very much or very closely, but it seems to me that he merely became popular by virtue of being the mayor of the city that suffered from a disaster. An inevitable spike to his popularity, just like how Bush received a spike to his popularity.
I’m not gonna judge or anything, but isn’t it a bit sad when a campaign emphasizes the horrible deaths of three thousand people, and wearing it like a badge of honor?
I was in New York that day-14 years old at the time.
and as you said. i remember him just walking around surveying the site. So I really do not know how his rise to Heroic status came about.
We should be honoring the 9/11 1st responders! who still today are not getting adequate treatment.
Isn’t it scary that people think he’ll be a good leader. He did nothing on Sept. 11, 2001, and he’ll do nothing in the White House.
Good blog post here!
Have you bothered reading his book?
The decider has pointed out many important questions.
I think that just about any mayor in any large city in this country, who would be thrown into the spotlight the way that G. was, would suddenly find themselves wearing that “hero” tag.
It just does not work for me like that! I have to have substance, and not the media and government hype so gloriously dished out day after day!!
This is your opinion, and you are fully free to say it.
What kind of man puts a “bunker” on the 23rd floor of a building? It cost $15m was bullet and bomb resistant and pretty much useless when it was really needed.
On that alone the man should never be allowed to hold government office again.
Giuliani: "9/11, 9/11, 9/11"!! But Does Anyone Know What He Actually Did?
This story has been submitted to Stirrdup. Your support can help it become hot.
Nicely written. Asking the question, what did he do to deserve being called a hero focuses thoughts on looking for substance instead of appearance. The next question that needs to be asked is, what didn’t he do that should have been done? For an in depth answer to that, you may want to contact Monona Rossel at http://www.artscraftstheatersafety.org/ – she and many other Occupational Hygienists volunteered to train clean up people in the proper use of respirators (which should have been used for health reasons) at their own expense. Rudy told them they weren’t needed. Now, people are dying of diseases directly related to the asbestos, silica, vaporized metals, etc. that were the aftermath of the towers being destroyed.
Talk to her – it will give you a whole new topic that needs to be explored when the man is running for president.
I’m guessing you’re right about Giuliani. However, I think we who want to criticize him more soundly are going to have to research more facts and list more sources.
I agree that he panders and has no thought for any but himself. His association with Bernard Kerik–former chief of police under Giuliani?–and the failed nomination of Kerik to head the Dept. of Homeland Security are the tip of the iceberg regarding Giuliani’s weaknesses: his past and his rewards to any willing to show fealty to the high and mighty G. Ethics and consequences be damned.
Good luck hunting him down.
http://rationalpsychic.wordpress.com
After thousands of wars ( A King’s sport) people realized that they must control the Kings -itching-to-go-to-wars. They added EIGHT words in their Constitution:
THE CONGRESS SHALL HAVE POWERS TO WAGE WAR.
The last two centuries saw the Kings denied the power to wage war.
But thanks to one word TERRORISTS the Kings, dictators and absolute rulers have gotten their full powers back. War or peace , its’ the KING’s war. Nobody can cry because the ducktaped mouths can only see , weep, but not shout.The word TERRORIST is the biggest KING REHABILITATING word of 5000 years. Only the KING/Dictator/absolute ruler is valid; rest humbug.
[...] (Grumpy Lion, 2007) [...]
Over at Ration Reality we considered backing Rudy … but it looks like he’s a non-starter. We’re endorsing Zombie Reagan now, as the only possible choice to save America.
What most people don’t realize is the reason Mr. G is actually running. Not because he offers anything to the country, or because he is qualified, but because he is perceived to have a better than average chance of winning. And the reason why this perception exists? Because of his exposure during 9/11. Most people that watched him couldn’t tell you anything positive that he did, other than get on camera acting like a mayor. He has positive name recognition, and that’s it. It’s a sad state of affairs, but the cruel reality is that in this country, for most voters, that’s all you need to be qualified to run. Look at Bush 43. If his last name had been Smith, Gore would have beat him handily in 2000.
Republican power brokers know that, the people with the money, the people who benefit from having a sympathetic man in office, and I will bet this years salary that they have pledged a significant amount of their support to him before he ever decided to throw his hat in the ring.
[...] said, something was brought up by fellow blogger Grumpy Lion regarding the republican race for the White House, specifically regarding Rudi Guliani. I like Rudi [...]
http://www.911reasons.com
Dear administration grumpylion.wordpress.com, I am assured, that I shall express the general opinion of all visitors and consequently on behalf of everything, I speak you the hugest thanks for creation and maintenance of such remarkable project!
Thanks!
As very much it would be desirable to hear something about plans for development of the project.
P.S. If our help is necessary – address, we always with pleasure shall help you!